This proposal was officially brought before the convention by william paterson of new jersey. What are the differences between the virginia and new. The smaller states opposed the virginia plan presented by james madison because they feared that it would allow the more populous states to dominate the government. Though it included provisions that the larger states would never agree to, it reasserted the smaller states position. The difference in the legislative branch between the new jersey plan and the virginia plan. Resolved, that the articles of confederation ought to be so corrected and enlarged as to accomplish the objects proposed by their institution, namely common defence, security of liberty and general welfare. This is a great packet of information about the virginia plan, new jersey plan and the great compromise. The new jersey plan has a unicameral government one house and the virginia plan has a bicameral government two houses. On june 15, however, william patterson presented the alternative new jersey plan. The virginia plan wants representation in congress to be based on population.
Students will read a statement and decide if it is a fact about the virginia plan or new jersey plan, then glue the box in the correct column. The great compromisethis powerpoint presentation examines. These plans were proposed when a group of state delegates gathered at the constitutional convention in 1787. It includes charts, graphs and a political cartoon. This system would split legislators into two houses, as opposed to the single assembly put forth by the new jersey plan, and legislators would be held to specified term limits. Honors constitution projectlance shepherd created using powtoon free sign up at youtube create animated videos and animated. The revised virginia plan and the new jersey plan teaching. Great compromise connecticut plan the smaller states supported the new jersey proposal, which led to a stalemate, as the big states would not turn away from the virginia plan. Questions are high level response, short answer questions.
Abicameral congress apportioned on the basis of population would have enabled the great states to dominate the new government. The plan was created in response to the virginia plan. The new jersey plan because it purposed a better stand point meaning national government and state. Compare how did the great compromise address the wishes of supporters of both the virginia and new jersey plans. Also known as the sherman compromise or the connecticut compromise, the deal combined proposals from the virginia large state plan and the new jersey small state plan. A compromise was reached yesterday june 29th, 1787 in philadelphia combining the new jersey plan and the virginia plan. New jersey plan definition, a plan, unsuccessfully proposed at the constitutional convention, providing for a single legislative house with equal representation for each state. The connecticut compromise established a bicameral legislature with the u. The delegates for the virginia plan were not too happy with the new jersey plan call for a weaker central government. Opposite of the virginia plan, it proposed a singlechamber congress in which each state had one vote. Which plan is better for the united states, the virginia plan or the new jersey plan. The virginia plan provided the framework, and after much debate, expansion, development, and compromise by the framers, became the constitution of the united states. How was the virginia plan better than the new jersey plan. William paterson proposed the new jersey, or small state, plan, which provided for equal representation in congress.
Constitutional convention june, 1787, june 15, 1787. The new jersey plan was the plan that the smaller states offered as their vision of how the new government of the united states should be structured. Mar 21, 2019 also known as the sherman compromise or the connecticut compromise, the deal combined proposals from the virginia large state plan and the new jersey small state plan. The issue was finally resolved with the compromise embodied in the bicameral congressrepresentation by population in the house of representatives, and equality of. The plan was submitted before the congress by the head of the virginia delegation, governor edmund randolph, on may 29, 1787. The plan was created in response to the virginia plan, which called for two houses of congress. Mix, from the people for one house, from the states for the other. On june, the delegates completed their second discussion of the virginia plan. The plan was created in response to the virginia plan, which called for two houses of congress, both elected with apportionment according to population. The new jersey plan offered multiple and expectative to be selected by the congress. The new jersey plan had one house based on equal representation of each state while the virginia plan had one house based upon the states population. The new jersey delegates to the constitutional convention, led by william paterson 17451806 proposed an alternative to the virginia.
He argued that the new jersey plan simply duplicated the defects of the articles and thus failed to address the source of the problem, namely, state sovereignty. This bundle contains 11 readytouse new jersey plan worksheets that are perfect for students who want to learn more about the new jersey plan, also known as the small state plan which was the counter proposal to the virginia plan. Virginia plan new jersey plan great compromise by zoopdog. It briefly formulated 15 resolutions that should define the powers and structure of the national government.
Specifically, the new jersey plan wanted to maintain onechamber legislation in which everyone had only one vote. How was the selection of representatives similar and different in the two earlier plans. The new jersey plan had two houses based on equal representation of each state while the virginia plan had one house based upon the states. The new jersey plan constitution of united states of. Jun 12, 2014 the great compromise combined elements of the new jersey plan, put forth by william paterson, that proposed two representatives from each state regardless of population, with the proposal that. James madison, alexander hamilton, george washington, ben. And, he argued further, that the virginia plan didnt. Virginia plan front side of the virginia plan 1787 created may 29, 1787 location national archives authors james madison purpose propose a structure of government to the philadelphia convention the virginia plan also known as the randolph plan, after its sponsor, or the largestate plan was a proposal by virginia delegates during the united states constitutional convention for a bicameral. The new jersey plan is the better plan for the united states.
Convention and ratification creating the united states. House of representatives apportioned by population, as desired by the virginia plan, and the. Derived from the people and based on popular representation. This created a conflict with representation between bigger states, who wanted control befitting their population, and smaller states, who didnt want to be bullied by larger states. Under the articles of confederation, each state had equal representation in congress, exercising one vote each. The difference between the new jersey plan and the virginia plan is the former proposed equal state representation in congress and the latter proposed state representation be determined by population. Also of interest are charles pinckneys plan, the new jersey plan, and the british plan. After the virginia plan was introduced, new jersey delegate william paterson asked for an adjournment to contemplate the plan.
William paterson, representing new jersey, took the lead in opposing the virginia plan. The virginia and new jersey plans were proposals of how to handle the issue of a federal legislature and how representation would be determined for the legislature. The new jersey plan was debated for four days, but the larger states rejected it. Senate being modeled after the structure in the new jersey plan. Patterson, laid before the convention the plan which he said several of the deputations wished to be substituted in place of that proposed by mr. The virginia plan suggested first and foremost that the united states govern by way of a bicameral legislature. Virginia and new jersey plans online library of liberty. William peterson of new jersey presented the plan to the convention on june 15, 1787. Dec 22, 2019 the new jersey plan was a methodology created by new jersey delegate william paterson, which outlined a system for the election of state representatives in a nationallyconsolidated legislature. The new jersey plan was put forward in response to the virginia plan. What features of both the virginia plan and the new jersey plan ended up in the constitution. This debate was much like the attack on the virginia plan when it comes to the issue on the number of representatives, but somewhat had a different twist. The virginia plan was used, but some ideas from the new jersey plan were added. On june 15th, 1787, the virginia plan was counteracted by the new jersey plan, also called the paterson plan or the small state plan.
The new jersey plan, which william paterson proposed to the constitutional convention, illustrated a unicameral legislation consisting of a single congressional legislative body in which each state would have an equal number of representatives. Articles of confederation and new jersey and virginia plan. Virginia plan new jersey plan yonkers public schools. The list of changes was drafted by james madison and presented to the convention by the governor of virgina, edmund randolph. Following two weeks of debate, paterson introduced. Perhaps the most important of these was introduced by the connecticut compromise, which established a bicameral legislature with the u. The key feature of pattersons proposal was giving equal power to. New jersey planthe adoption of the virginia plan by the constitutional convention of 1787 frightened state sovereignty supporters and nationalists from small states.
Dec 17, 2018 the virginia plan suggested first and foremost that the united states govern by way of a bicameral legislature. Dec 12, 2019 the new jersey plan was a proposal for the structure of the united states federal government, presented by william paterson at the constitutional convention of 1787. A bicameral legislature every state had two members in the senate house of representatives was filled by population each five. Resolved, that the articles of confederation ought to be so revised, corrected, and enlarged as to render the federal constitution adequate to the exigencies of government, and the preservation of the union. Gw probably made his copy of the new jersey plan of government on the day that william paterson presented it to the convention. In the constitutional convention, the virginia plan favored large states while the new jersey plan favored small states. The new jersey plan, on the other hand, represented the states with smaller populations.
Inherited from the articles of confederation, this. Plan, alternately called the new jersey plan or the paterson plan, proposed on june 15, 1787. In contrast to the virginia plan, the new jersey plan proposed a unicameral legislature with one vote per state. The great compromise combined elements of the new jersey plan, put forth by william paterson, that proposed two representatives from each state. Describe the virginia plan and new jersey plan answers. The new jersey plan was a proposal for the structure of the united states federal government, presented by william paterson at the constitutional convention of 1787. Bicameral each state is represented equally but in unicameral each state is represented by its population. The 19 resolutions of the amended virginia plan preserved the new institutional structure proposed by the original plan. Sep 14, 2017 honors constitution projectlance shepherd created using powtoon free sign up at youtube create animated videos and animated. Resolved, that provision be made for the admission of new states into the union. This position reflected the belief that the states were independent entities and as they entered the united states of america freely and individually, so they remained.
Virginia plan, new jersey plan and the great compromise. Learn vocabulary, terms, and more with flashcards, games, and other study tools. It called for a onehouse congress and proposed that each state have one representative, regardless of the. What are the similarities between new jersey plan and. The document was a response to the virginia plan, which would have given proportional power to the states based on their number of citizens. Elements of the new jersey plan were incorporated into the proposal that emerged from the virginia plan. Patterson2 laid before the convention the plan which he said several of the deputations wished to be substituted in place of that proposed by mr. Also the new jersey focus was to make all states to have equal representation regardless on. Oct 09, 2008 this debate was much like the attack on the virginia plan when it comes to the issue on the number of representatives, but somewhat had a different twist. New jersey plan opposite of the virginia plan, it proposed a singlechamber congress in which each state had one vote. The new jersey plan was a proposed government for the united states developed by william paterson in 1787. The final result of the debates between the virginia and new jersey plan was the great compromise connecticut compromise that was a combination of both plans. The virginia plan was used, but some ideas from the new jersey plan were added as a part of the great compromise. The new jersey plan also known as the small state plan or the paterson plan was a proposal for the structure of the united states government presented by william paterson at the constitutional convention on june 15, 1787.
Government divided into 3 branches executive, legislative and judicial 4. The virginia plan was by the people where as the new jersey plan was by the states. Sort each proposal by placing it beneath the states that. The new jersey plan was a unicameral and the new jersey plan was bicameral. The difference in the legislative branch between the new. On june 15th, 1787 the virginia plan was countered by the new jersey plan, also called the paterson plan or the small state plan. James madison wrote the virginia plan, which called for states with larger populations to have more representation in the government. Neither the virginia nor the new jersey plans were immediately printed for. It was presented to the convention on may 29, 1787. What are the differences between the virginia and new jersey. Connecticut compromise the connecticut compromise was a combination of the virginia and new jersey plans it called for. The constitutional convention boundless political science.
668 1477 17 886 1059 1008 1299 272 796 1114 667 580 1359 989 472 142 1631 491 1202 241 1541 1481 1195 1052 243 1057 1397 1043 1324 620 954 483 776 1333 1410 33 945 479 422 734 442 257 805